The Signal
Researchers Model a Charge-Noise Fix for SAGE Spin Qubits
A study of SAGE spin qubits uses simulations to examine whether refocusing pulses can reduce charge-noise errors while preserving the qubits’ protection against magnetic-field gradients. The modeled pulses extend idle coherence, and an echo pulse reduces two-qubit gate infidelity under the conditions studied.

Published November 2 in Physical Review B, a study of singlet-only always-on gapless exchange (SAGE) spin qubits examines a tradeoff in their design: protection against magnetic-field gradients comes with increased sensitivity to charge noise. Nathan L. Foulk, Katharina Laubscher, Silas Hoffman and Sankar Das Sarma use numerical calculations to test whether refocusing pulses can mitigate that noise. The results concern a modeled system, not measurements on a fabricated SAGE device.
Source arxiv.org
Four dots, one singlet-only qubit
A SAGE qubit encodes information in the spins of four electrons held in four tunnel-coupled quantum dots. The singlet-only encoding makes its computational subspace invariant under magnetic-field gradients, which can cause errors in conventional exchange-only qubits. Always-on exchange couplings provide energetic protection against leakage from computational states.
That continuous coupling also increases sensitivity to charge noise. Fluctuations in gate voltages change the dots’ chemical potentials and the tunnel couplings between them, altering the exchange interactions that control the qubit. The researchers describe the dot system with a Hubbard model and include time-dependent 1/f charge noise, as well as quasistatic magnetic noise, in their calculations.
Pulse sequences target charge fluctuations
The study evaluates dynamical-decoupling sequences based on repeated rotations around the qubit’s y axis. In SAGE, those rotations are built from x- and z-axis operations, which the researchers use as components of their CPMG-like pulse sequences. They analyze several sequence designs, including CPMG-8 and CPMG-16, and model noise during the pulses as well as during idle periods.
The calculations show that applying more pulses can extend idle coherence. For realistic charge-noise amplitudes in the model, a 32-pulse sequence produces a coherence time on the order of 100 microseconds. The paper also reports that pulse imperfections become more noticeable as pulse numbers rise; its symmetrized CPMG-16 sequence better cancels those errors than the basic CPMG sequence in the comparison presented. Short idle gaps between component x and z pulses cause only a slight reduction in the calculated coherence times.
“Such pulses extend the SAGE single-qubit coherence times to hundreds of microseconds for a wide range of experimentally relevant charge noise magnitudes.”
—The authors of the study write.
An echo pulse for a modeled two-qubit gate
For two-qubit operations, the team studies a controlled-Z gate formed by switching on exchange between neighboring SAGE qubits. Their proposed echo inserts a refocusing pulse halfway through the interqubit exchange pulse. In the calculations, the echo suppresses low-frequency charge-noise errors on the individual qubits. The paper reports fidelities above 99% for the modeled gates and says this result does not require correcting noise in the entangling interaction itself.
The improvement is conditional on the modeled gate parameters. Longer ramps of the entangling pulse help suppress leakage into states outside the computational subspace. In the adiabatic regime, the authors report that the echo reduces gate infidelity by almost an order of magnitude. That is a reduction in infidelity, not an increase in fidelity by that amount. Without optimizing the exchange ratio, adding an echo can slightly increase leakage.
Gate speed and noise remain linked
The calculations also examine the relationship between the maximum exchange coupling, gate speed and noise. A larger coupling can enable a faster gate, but it also increases the effects of charge noise on the always-on couplings within each qubit. Along the operating path studied, the competing effects leave infidelity approximately constant as the maximum coupling changes.
The paper presents refocusing pulses as a modeled way to mitigate charge noise in SAGE qubits, whose singlet-only encoding and always-on exchange protect against magnetic-gradient errors and leakage. The authors note that the architecture requires four dots in a noncollinear arrangement and simultaneous control of exchange couplings. Whether the modeled performance can be achieved in devices remains an experimental question.